Layered Jello
This is an old, typical Hawaii potluck recipe for Layered Jello. Always gorgeous for parties!
Ingredients:
4 packages JELLO (3 oz each) -
orange, lime, blue rasberry, strawberry
6 envelopes KNOX unflavored gelatin
1 cup sweetened condensed milk
Mix 1 cup condensed milk with 1 cup hot water. Set aside. Mix 2 envelopes Knox gelatin with 1 cup hot water; combine with milk mixture and set aside
Combine Orange JELLO, 1 envelope Knox gelatin and 1-1/2 cups hot water. Cool, then pour into a 9×13 pyrex. Place in refrigerator to set for about 30 minutes.
*Note – the Hawaii version says to grease pan with mayonnaise – the thought of that makes me want to vomit. I hate mayonaisse. We just poured it in as is and it didn’t stick, thank god, cause everyone knows – mayonaisse=barf. HA!
Pour about 1 cup of the milk mixture for the next later. Refrigerate to set. Now each layer will only take 15 minutes to set – yay – much faster!
Combine lime JELLO, 1 envelope Knox gelatin and 1-1/2 cup hot water. Cook, and pour carefully over the milk mixture, then place in the refridgerator for another 15 minutes.
Repeat the milk mixture….
Now the blue raspberry…
Then the milk mixture…(I know this is boring but the payoff is worth it…)
Finally end with the strawberry! And set til you’re ready to serve…
The final product looks like this, and when you cut it…GORGEOUS!!
Man, I love this jello! I just made broken glass jello – thanks for the inspiration!!!
This is great! Can’t wait to try it. You inspired me to blog about all things rainbow today, and I included your layered jello
Now THIS is seriously cool! And so beautiful.
I made this today for my daughter’s birthday! Way fun. I had a little trouble but I’m guessing it’s just a practice makes perfect thing. My green layer kind of melted into the white layer so the blue layer I let set longer before adding the final white layer but the white mixture then set up in the bowl that I’d set aside and I had to spread it on instead of pour it on, it was no longer a liquid…. So the top layer looks a little funky, you can tell through the red layer that the top white layer is all lumpy and what not…. I figure I’ll serve it upside down and maybe no one will notice…. We’ll try this one again! Thanks for sharing it!!!
Where did you find the KNOX unflavored gelatin? I tried Wal-Mart but had no luck!
Try any major supermarket, it should be in the jello/baking aisle!
I’m doing this right now and having the same melting problem… guess I need my jello to be cooler and I need each layer to set longer. I’m only two color layers in, so there’s still hope it won’t look totally gross…
Hm. Yeah – don’t pour it in boiling hot, but don’t exactly let it set either. It is practice makes perfect unfortunately…
Hi there
…found this recipe after a search & am excited to try it, along with so many others on your site! Everything looks delish & fun–my kids are going to flip. Quick Q though–how far in advance can I make the layered jello dessert? Want to make it for a bday party but need to make it ahead. Thanks!
Personally, I would only make it the day before. I’ve seen problems where people have made it early and the layers start to separate. You don’t want that!
Great website,you’re a very clever lady. I use the layered jello for making vodka shooters.Substitute 1/4 cup of vodka when mixing jello,and a 1/2 cup for the milk mixture. Usually make creamsicle shooters using orange jello and flavored vodkas. everyone loves them! My hats off to you!! Thanks.
This is too cute – I’m going to make it for the 4th of July with red/white/blue/white/red. Can’t wait to see what the kids think!
I had this yesterday at my sister’s baby shower and had no luck calling her this morning to get it. Thanks to you… I have it! YAAAY! ;D
made it for 4th of july with blueberry, strawberry and the milk layer. looked great and everyone loved it. making it again this weekend for a toga birthday party with a couple different flavors. i expect it will go over just the same. thanks for helping me find this. was given the recepie but it omitted the water in the milk. could not figure out why it never set and why the can did not go the distance!
I have been using this recipe for years, and I get so many compliments! It’s a time consuming process, but it’s worth it, as it’s always a hit at my children’s parties and potluck events. I refer many of my friends and coworkers to this website who want to know how to make layered Jell-O. Thanks for sharing your wonderful recipe!!!
My aunt makes this every year for famliy get togethers, it is a classic, and super delicious!
I’ve recently started a blog, the information you provide on this site has helped me tremendously. Thank you for all of your time & work.
Looks b’ful Jenn,want to take it to potluck this week…have a doubt though…the recipe says ”Combine Orange JELLO, 1 envelope Knox gelatin and 1-1/2 cups hot water. Cool, then pour into a 9×13 pyrex”Similarly for all the other flavors,1 envelope each gelatin is added.
Am wondering,why add the gelatin to the jello,will not the jello set by itself with appropriate amt of boiling water…will the addition of gelatin make it more rubbery?
Kindly revert,would love to make it and I don;t want to bungle up this recipe…thanks.
Jenn Nomura?
I tried the recipe. It turned out pretty well at first, but by the time I got to the last layer of milk mixture, it had already solidified in the bowl. Needless to say, it was pretty difficult to spread to all sections of the pan. I ended up scraping most of it off and just put the red layer over the blue layer. You can still see solidified bits of the milk mixture under the red layer, so presentation won’t be as nice I would have liked.
Thank you so much for this recipe! I’m from HI, and had a craving for this jello (it’s the only way I can even eat jello). I haven’t had it in years, so I didn’t think I could even remember what this was called so I randomly googled “layered jello,” and there it was! Thanks again, I’ll definitely be making this for my kids some time soon.
=)
@ratasha
I’m with you, I’m not much of a Jello fan except when it’s served like this or when it’s Broken Glass Jello, otherwise, forget it!
Yummy Jenn! Exactly likes mom’s. I used to call it old school jello recipe cause I didn’t know what it’s name was. So happy to find this. About the issue some replies had with the milk mixture set/solidify before the last red layer put on. I recommend they do the 2nd paragraph of instructions 1st (do the orange jello instruction) then after it has already set in the fridge 30min. as you instructed, then they should do the 1st paragraph of instruction (the milk mix). Basically by switching the order of these 2 instructions it’s 30min. of less time for the milk mix to sit out and start to set. Also many folks who are doing this in cooler/cold air (a/c unit, cold climate) the milk will set quicker as opposed to those living in the islands or warmer locations. As for the melting prob., you mention in the very first (orange) jello mix instruction “cool, then pour”. This step is important to follow. =) Thank you for sharing Jenn, love it!
i have the same problem – the jello isn’t set hard enough and when i pour the white, it totally bleeds into the red. i’m gonna let it cool longer so the white doesn’t bleed. keep my fingers across. i believe the knox gelatin helps the jello become wiggly and not fall apart when you cut.
hiiie
I ended up bow most of it off and righteous put the red place over the amytal sheet. You can solace see solid bits of the river variety low the red stratum, so show won’t be as overnice I would person likeable……….
……….
hedden
……………………………
Cooking
So cute! Tried it out, wow, I didn’t realized it would take so long, but it turned out great. My refrigerator was slightly tilted so I kept turning the pan and it ended up being topsy turvy. Will definitely do again but probably in clear plastic cups
Thanks so much for posting this recipe! my grandparents lived in Hawaii for 20 years and i remember going to visit as a child and my grandmother making this. I wanted to make it for my kids, but no one in the family could find the recipe so i turned to the internet. I’m sure my children will love it and it will bring back fantastic childhood memories for me!!!! Thanks again!!!!
Thanks for the great pictures. I do realize that the white mixture should be not hot and a little luke warm. My first white layer was a little pink from the jello below. But otherwise, I can’t wait to cut them up. I also put a little canola oil around the pan to help it come out easier.
What makes the milk harden?
How much in advance can this be made? Having a party on Saturday. Can I make it on Thursday or Wednesday? Thanks!
@notsogoodcook:
You can make it in advance no problem, in fact I SUGGEST it. It frees up your time for more party planning!
When you say “hot water” (in all of the jello steps), do you mean “boiling”, like what you normally need for jello?
@notsogoodcook
Yes, hot or boiling, just like when you make a batch of regular jello.
I just LOVE this recipe altho, as stated, it does take time and can be tricky. Good to know it can be made a couple of days in advance.
Had the same “milk mixture too stiff” problem so I tried it preparing the milk in two batches. It didnt work for some reason – messy and still too stiff – so will try mixing it up AFTER the first jello layer is set, gaining 30 mins in this race.
Thanks everyone for the input.
I think this is the first time I’ve ever thought Jello was “pretty”. Ooo, pretty.
Now you are making me crave rainbow jello. Brings back childhood memories. Gotta make this myself now.
just curious… does this still work if you just do the jello layers (no white layers)? Will the jello stick together without the white?
I made this and my son loves it, he needed a dessert for school and said he would bring jello some of the kids said they dont like jello but he assured them they will like this one. Thank you sooo much love the reciepe.
haha, mayonaise = barf….so true!! I used Pam cooking spray. I am hoping my cream layer sets, so far it seems too liquidy
oh haaaaayyyyy, the creamy part thickened, so we got first two layers going. w00t! tanks!
What a great idea. I cannot wait to try it out at my Christmas Party.
You’ve inspired me to try this! Thank you for taking the time to post it. ♥
We make these for Gator Games and just use Blue and Orange. I am going to make these for the kids this Superbowl Sunday. One batch of yellow and green another batch of blue, yellow, and red. (I would rather be using Giants colors) I love how you can just choose the colors to fit anything. Pink and red for valentines, green for st. patty’s, red and green for Christmas, softer colors for Easter. For my son’s super hero party we are making red and blue. These are awesome and the kids like to peel them apart too.
MILK LAYER GETS LAYER GETS LUMPY:
When the sweetened condensed milk layer gets lumpy or gels together between adding layers then just pop it in the microwave for 30 seconds and stir with a wisk. Works like a CHARM!!!!
This looks amazing! I’ve only seen really thick layers before.
Clear out a shelf in your refrigerator for your glass dish …. then just keep your dish in the refrigerator and pour the jello in. Don’t move the dish in and out of the frige! Also, don’t rush the layers – they really do need to set up well before you pour the next layer in. I make this recipe with 6 layers so I’ll do 3 layers in the evening and then the other 3 layers the next morning.
Do you have any idea how to turn this into an alcoholic treat? I’m getting confused on what part you’re supposed to replace water with alochol…not sure if you ever do this with your jello recipes!
@Joanna
Sorry, no idea!
This recipe has become a regular for this household. (From Japan to Sacramento to now, Germany) I originally did this recipe and your shave ice cupcakes for a Spongebob/Luau party my son was having. They were both a hit. The kids LOVED the jello and even the adults were fooled by the cupcakes. I did use the mayo to prevent sticking for the jello. I’m a little ahem, “detail oriented” (insert less PC word here!) that way and, can’t even taste it. Ignorance it bliss in this situation for my family
I’ve tried both without mayo and with mayo and with the mayo, it does slip out easier (though both ways works fine in my pyrex). Thanks for everything you do! I’m always tuned in!
I’ve been sitting here biting my nails trying to decide whose layered jello recipe to use and you win! I’ll write soon to let you know how it goes. Thanks for posting!